Burgers are one of those foods everyone has a strong, slightly irrational opinion about. Ask ten different Lloydminster locals for their favorite, and you'll get ten confident, slightly competitive answers. We dug through what locals actually say — not just star ratings, but the specific dishes they keep ordering — and put together a ranked list you can actually trust.
1. The Proper
Consistently mentioned as a top pick, The Proper earns its reputation with dishes locals specifically call out by name — one regular praised the Swiss mushroom burger as the best in town, with the only critique being a request for more gravy on the side. Another local specifically mentioned it as a birthday dinner tradition, calling it always a treat, though it's worth noting it's not open for lunch.
Order this: The Swiss mushroom burger.
2. Fatburger
A reliable favorite for travelers passing through, Fatburger has built a loyal local customer base, with regulars specifically calling it their go-to lunch stop when driving through Lloydminster, praising both the service and the food quality on repeat visits.
Order this: The classic Fatburger, the namesake dish for a reason.
3. Maggie Mae's Family Restaurant
Already a local breakfast favorite, Maggie Mae's holds its own in the burger category too, ranking consistently among the top local picks alongside its well-known breakfast specials and bottomless coffee.
Order this: Ask about the daily special — locals note it changes but consistently delivers.
4. Cheers
Best known for catering and comfort food, Cheers also earns a spot here thanks to standout menu items like the Monster Cheers Burger and the Mother Clucker Chicken Burger — names locals specifically remember and reorder.
Order this: The Monster Cheers Burger, for anyone who wants their burger to be an event.
5. Original Joe's Restaurant & Bar
A dependable bar-and-grill favorite, Original Joe's shows up often in local burger conversations, with regulars specifically calling their burgers huge and very, very good — messy, but in the best way.
Order this: The barbecue bacon cheeseburger, a repeat order for plenty of regulars.
6. The Clock Tower Pasta and Burger
Landing consistently in local top-10 burger rankings, this spot pairs its burger menu with pasta options, making it a solid pick if your group can't agree on Italian versus American comfort food.
7. Gold Horse Casino Bar & Grill
Don't overlook the casino for a solid burger — locals recommend trying the steak sandwich here specifically, and players-card holders get a small discount, making it a practical stop if you're already spending an evening at the casino.
Order this: The steak sandwich, according to regulars who've tried it more than once.
8. Carl's Jr.
A dependable chain option that consistently earns praise locally for hot, fresh food and genuinely attentive service — one family specifically mentioned staff going out of their way to accommodate a simple request, calling the overall visit excellent.
Order this: The Carl Burger, the most frequently mentioned menu item.
9. The Green Glacier Eatery
A smaller, locally loved spot that shows up on multiple local "best of" lists, including for burgers specifically — a good pick if you're looking for something a little less mainstream than the chain options.
10. Umami Cuisine
Rounding out the list, Umami earns a spot in local burger rankings alongside its broader menu — worth trying if you want a burger from a spot that also does other cuisines well.
Honorable Mentions
A&W, Dairy Queen Grill & Chill, and Burger King all maintain a steady local presence, and while they won't top this list, they remain dependable, no-fuss options — Burger King in particular gets consistent praise locally for good service and affordable prices, especially for a quick meal near Sandy Beach Regional Park.
The Honest Local Take
What's clear from digging through local reviews is that Lloydminster's best burgers aren't concentrated in one type of restaurant — sit-down spots like The Proper and Original Joe's compete directly with fast-food staples like Fatburger and Carl's Jr., and regulars are loyal to specific menu items more than specific restaurants. If there's a pattern, it's this: locals gravitate toward burgers that are messy, generous, and named after something specific — the Monster Cheers Burger, the double-fatburger, the Swiss mushroom burger — rather than anything overly polished.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best burger in Lloydminster?
The Proper is frequently named a top pick, particularly for its Swiss mushroom burger, though Fatburger and Maggie Mae's are close local favorites too.
Is there a good burger spot for a sit-down dinner?
Yes — The Proper, Original Joe's Restaurant & Bar, and The Clock Tower Pasta and Burger are all solid choices for a proper sit-down burger meal.
Are there fast-food burger options locals actually recommend?
Yes. Fatburger and Carl's Jr. both earn consistent local praise for quality and service, standing out among the chain options.
Can you get a good burger at Gold Horse Casino?
Yes — while better known for its steak sandwich, the casino's bar and grill is a solid, convenient option if you're already spending an evening there.
Is there a burger spot good for large orders or catering?
Yes — Cheers has built a strong reputation for both individual burger orders and large catering requests.
Craving more local food guides? Check out our Best Restaurants in Lloydminster and Lloydminster's Best Pizza roundups for even more ways to eat like a local.